Tuesday, February 24, 2009

73% of percentages are statistics...right?

My Thought: Research methods and justifications are unique to your socialization experience

So I’ve noticed more and more people have been citing statistics in their normal conversations. My friends do it, I over hear it when I’m inconspicuously eaves dropping on strangers, and I’ve fallen victim to the trend. I sprinkle my political discussions with them whether or not they are correct and surprisingly gain instant credibility with my audience. I am even more likely to believe a friend if they can back it up with some type of statistic or innocuous quote or source on the topic. But like my AP psych teacher Mr. Swope told me in high school: 42% of statistics are made up!

When people socially use statistics to their advantage, how do you tell them their information is wrong? Or better yet, how do you tell someone their information is obsolete?

Why does it matter that 72% of the country agrees with you on this matter? Should that sway my judgment? Naw. But the truth is, it does. And I have been wondering if constantly seeking mass support to feel secure in one’s own opinion is simply a feature of American society…kind of like a reification* of our innate democratic tendencies as Americans… or is it present in every society?

My theory is that a person’s social structure, as represented in their system of government, not only affects their way of thinking but way of researching as well. As an American, I have been taught that the more sources I have to back me up, the more likely it is that I am correct. I think this is because of our democratic government that teaches us that we ultimately do not value independent thought. Move with the masses or become outcast as a minority.

We see this on even the most basic levels of decision making. In fifth grade recess I remember having to choose between playing kickball or king of the hill. We voted and the majority chose our fate. Why didn’t the biggest, strongest kid just come along and decide for us? Why didn’t we separate and let everyone do what they want? The kids who “lost” in the vote still played kickball with us, apparently upset but still acquiescing.

My question then is how do the research methods of people in dictatorships, monarchies or oligarchies differ from ours?

Is our society more focused on persuasion than Cuba’s?

Why is it when someone writes a book without any sources it is considered mere opinion and devalued as such but when someone writes a book with the same outcome and messages but can reinforce it with other information, it is considered credible? Is a book with 8 sources of incorrect material more valuable than a book with none?

Why do I ask so many questions?


Walk away from this post and think about the ways you justify your opinions. Can we ever be self-justified?



*shout out to Professor Wright for teaching me this beautiful word...and blame him accordingly for its misuse!