Monday, June 14, 2010

Drawing the line

Here is a brief/policy memo I prepared on an event I went to last week. I have done projects on gerrymandering in the past (as it relates to the electoral college and it's affect on the distribution of resources for underprivileged and urban areas) so I was oddly intrigued by the thought of an anti-gerrymandering campaign. The film however, seemed really spastic and although it presents multiple angles to this complex problem, it never proves the underlying assumption that gerrymandering is bad. I actually left the event more confident in my support for gerrymandering-hell, keep the power while ya got it. Here's the brief and my additional opinions are at the bottom!


Gerrymandering
June 10, 2010. 7pm.
Landmark E Street Theater, Washington DC
Hosted by IMPACT Arts, Film Fund, Green Film Company
Presented the film Gerrymandering, a documentary that looks at the historical relevance and present manifestation and harms for gerrymandering.

Policy
The event and filmed focused on the passing of Proposition 11 in California in November of 2008. Prop 11 or The Voters First Act prevents state legislators from drawing the lines that create the legislative districts. Instead, a group of citizens will comprise a commission that will be responsible for creating fair lines. In order to join the commission a registered voter must that apply for the position, are screened by the State Auditor for conflicts of interest then the most qualified candidates are chosen to move to the final applicant pool. From there State Legislators can strike at their discretion and the final members are chosen at random by the State Auditor.

Pros
• Gets politicians directly out of process of redistricting
• Empowers and rewards active citizens that have voted
• The commission can ensure equity and diversity
• In theory, can create bi-partisan cooperation by mandating that both parties be equally represented on the commission
• In theory, the legislation can create political competition

Cons
• Very little empirical evidence that draws a causal relationship between district lines and election outcomes
• Commissioners must be financially compensated
• State Legislators have can control who is on the commission and must approve the final map. Therefore it may not prevent all bias from entering the redistricting process.
• The commission can override the constituents’ voices
• Increases bureaucracy


Speakers & Talking Points
• Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger supported the proposition in California because he believed it “put the power back in the hands of the people”. He worked with the organization Smart Vote and even donated upwards of $2.5 million to the $14 million campaign.

• Congressman John Tanner believes there is urgency to pass similar legislation on a federal level as the federal redistricting occurs April 2010. He is stepping down from Congress this year. He believes gerrymandering creates an atmosphere that is “too partisan to work” often polarizing the politicians and preventing progress.

• Fmr Congressman Martin Frost lost his seat after the 2003 redistricting in Texas under Tom Delay. He believes the current laws keep the “people from voting for who they want to vote for.” Advocate for new federal legislation that will change redistricting laws

Relevant to Maryland
Governor O'Malley recently passed the No Representation without Population, which prevents counties with prisons from claiming the prisoners as a part of their population. This will re-shift a lot of population and consequently political power in the upcoming redistricting process. The film applauded the legislation. Maryland has already taken a large step in ensuring fairness in the re-districting process. The Voters First Act may interfere with that progress as it prematurely assesses the needs of a community and may reapportion power incorrectly.

Questions for further analysis
• The film admits Gerrymandering has occurred since the nation’s inception so why is it “threatening the very basis of democracy” now?
• After losing 6 times prior, the people in favor of Prop 11 outspent their opponents 14-1 and still only won by at 2% margin. Was this something the people really wanted?
• How will the legislation affect the incumbency rate in the California legislature?
• How can we ensure fairness on the commission if there is no oversight?
• Is there a such thing as an un-gerrymandered district?

In My Opinion
Gerrymandering is comparable to the President's right to assign someone tenure on the Supreme Court-it's one of the political goodies that keeps our system afloat. Also, if done correctly, it can help balance some of the political inequities within our system. One example of this was Congressman Frost's anecdote about Texas losing it's seniority within Congress due to the redistricting and the democrats losing their seats. I thought that was a good thing. Had there not been a regime change Texans would chair 3 of the most important committees within Congress. That is a political travesty. We need balance.

Also, the movie tried to create this faux sense of urgency when in reality, not only has gerrymandering has been around since the nation's foundation but also there is no way to NOT gerrymander! How can any line be drawn that does not separate two things? Whether that is based on race, socioeconomic status, or political party, there is no such thing as blind re-districting. I argue any attempt at "blind redistricting" would destroy communities and political identities. I believe that threatens democracy just as much as any attempt at uplifting an identity.

Another thing about the movie that bothered me was the dependence on soundbite politicking. Governor Schwarzenegger claimed the process was too complex to explain to the people in soundbites and that they doubted the ability of the public to grasp the gravity of the situation. I HATE THIS COP OUT! Don't, in one hand, say you want "public participation" or that you want to "empower the people" but on the other hand patronize the very people you say you seek to serve. Sure, not every citizen gets hot and bothered about which district they live in but don't assume their ignorance is completely irrational. More than likely, the people are indifferent about their districts because they do not see any tangible (policy) affects of redistricting. Maybe it doesn't matter who is governing because they don't seem to be making that big of a difference in their lives either way.

I will say this, although I am not completely opposed to gerrymandering, I do with the public had a larger say in the process. An easy remedy to the ills of gerrymandering would be to let the public vote on the districting options in a referendum. Let each party and the State Auditor submit a map to the public and let them decide how they want to live! If you really want to empower the people, don't create another bureaucracy and drown out their voices, let them vote!

I could write a book (or at least a few more paragraphs) on the complexities of gerrymandering but I'm sure you've stopped reading by now! ; )

Sources
Balganorth, Robert. "Prop. 11 Is Sham Redistricting Reform - Vote No - SFGate." Featured Articles From The SFGate. Web. 11 June 2010. .

"BILL INFO-2010 Regular Session-SB 400." Maryland General Assembly Home Page. Web. 11 June 2010. .

"California Proposition 11 (2008) - Ballotpedia." Web. 11 June 2010. .

The California Voter Foundation. Web. 11 June 2010. .

End Gerrymandering. Web. 11 June 2010. .
Gerrymandering A New Documentary Film. Web. 11 June 2010. .

"Proposition 11: Redistricting - California State Government." Smart Voter by the League of Women Voters. Comprehensive, Nonpartisan Election Information. Web. 11 June 2010. .

No comments: